Building Shopify apps?Bestappify for developers
All appsScored ranking · updated weekly

Best Shopify Warranties and Insurance Apps

The 30 strongest of the 94 warranties and insurance apps in our index of the Shopify App Store category chart, scored on four things we measure ourselves: how many stores use it, how well those stores rate it, whether it is gaining or losing ground, and what it costs. No editor picks the order, and nobody can pay to move up it.

Apps in category
94
Top score
72
With a free plan
22 of 30
Rank tracked for
4 days

The short answer

Five ways to be the right warranties and insurance app. Each award is the highest scorer that fits it, and no app can win twice.

Best overall

The highest total score in the category: 92 reviews at 4.9, and 91.5 out of 100 on adoption against every other warranties and insurance app.

Best free option

The strongest app here with no paid tier at all — 21 reviews, rated 5.0, and $0 whatever your volume.

Best paid app

No free tier, so the price component holds it down the ranked list — but 82 merchants rate it 5.0, and it starts at $9.95/month.

Most established

483 reviews — more than anything else Shopify files under warranties and insurance — and still rated 5.0.

The full ranking

Sorted by BestAppify Score. The four bars under each app are its percentile within this category on each component — a 90 on adoption means only a tenth of warranties and insurance apps have more reviews.

  1. 1
    Sam Shipping Protection Upsell

    Shipping protection covers stolen or damaged items while you keep 100% of the fees. Customize protection plans based on cart subtotals (fixed, percentage, range

    4.9(92)Free · then $9Category rank 5 0
    72
    score
    Adoption
    92
    Satisfaction
    83
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  2. 2
    Xcotton Post Purchase Guard

    Xcotton offers insurance-backed shipping protection that helps brands protect every order against common shipping risks, including lost packages, d...

    5(483)Category rank 1 0
    71
    score
    Adoption
    100
    Satisfaction
    100
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    40
    View on the Shopify App Store
  3. 3
    Shipping Protection —Shipcheck

    Increase order value with Shipping Protection at cart and checkout on your Shopify store. Offset cost of lost, damaged or stolen orders and build customer trust

    5(82)$9.95/moCategory rank 6 0
    70.3
    score
    Adoption
    89
    Satisfaction
    98
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    65
    View on the Shopify App Store
  4. 4
    Supercart

    Fully customizable Shopify cart drawer with powerful unlimited bundles, product recommendations, Upsells, reviews and Extra Services to increase revenue & con..

    5(34)Free · then $9Category rank 13 0
    68.9
    score
    Adoption
    72
    Satisfaction
    95
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  5. 5
    Insureful Shipping Protection

    Add shipping protection to cart & checkout. Offer fixed or % insurance, exclude items, handle claims, and keep 100% of fees. Package Protection.

    4.9(64)Free · then $9.95Category rank 8 0
    68.4
    score
    Adoption
    85
    Satisfaction
    79
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  6. 6
    Captain Shipping Protection

    shopify shipping protection, shipping insurance shopify, shopify insurance app, shopify shipping protection, navidum, aftership insurance, parcelpanel insurance

    4.9(278)$11/moCategory rank 3 0
    66.7
    score
    Adoption
    96
    Satisfaction
    88
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    45
    View on the Shopify App Store
  7. 7
    VOL Shipping Protection Upsell

    Shipping protection upsell with custom pricing, package protection, shipping claims, and coverage for lost, damaged, or stolen orders at cart and checkout pages

    5(21)Free · then $15Category rank 17 0
    64.5
    score
    Adoption
    64
    Satisfaction
    91
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  8. 8
    SHIPAID ‑ Shipping Guarantee

    ShipAid boosts revenue and customer satisfaction with customizable shipping guarantee. Easily manage lost or damaged orders with a user friendly portal.

    5(21)FreeCategory rank 16 0
    64.5
    score
    Adoption
    64
    Satisfaction
    91
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  9. 9
    Navidium Shipping Protection

    Alternative to shipping insurance, self-fund your own shipping protection with our integrated widget. Route Shipping Protection fees to yourself. Keep 100%.

    4.8(330)Free · then $29.99Category rank 2 0
    63.5
    score
    Adoption
    98
    Satisfaction
    48
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  10. 10
    PMO: ProtectMyOrder

    ProtectMyOrder enables merchants to upsell premium services at checkout. Sell services such as shipping protection, carbon neutral shipping and fre...

    5(12)FreeCategory rank 23+2
    63.3
    score
    Adoption
    53
    Satisfaction
    86
    Momentum
    20
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  11. 11
    Warranty Registration & Claims

    Dyrect offers easy warranty management. Track serial numbers, manage product registration, process claims, and automate customer support.

    4.9(21)Free · then $19Category rank 18 0
    58.8
    score
    Adoption
    64
    Satisfaction
    71
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  12. 12
    SureBright Product Protection

    Boost profits & customer trust. Sell extended warranty, product warranty, product protection, shipping insurance. AI-powered quick and easy Shopify integration.

    4.8(50)FreeCategory rank 9 0
    57.6
    score
    Adoption
    83
    Satisfaction
    45
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  13. 13
    Umbrella: In‑house Warranties

    Sell AppleCare-style protection plans on your Shopify store with Umbrella. Boost revenue, reduce chargebacks, and manage claims seamlessly—all under your brand.

    5(9)Free · then $249Category rank 25+2
    57.4
    score
    Adoption
    45
    Satisfaction
    76
    Momentum
    20
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  14. 14
    Simply Shipping Protection

    Let customers protect orders with cart-level shipping protection, manage claims through our app, and earn extra revenue with customizable widgets and upsells.

    4.6(120)Free · then $4.99Category rank 4 0
    52.8
    score
    Adoption
    94
    Satisfaction
    17
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  15. 15
    CPS Extended Warranty Upsell

    Turn existing Shopify traffic into additional profit with built-in warranty upsells from CPS! Our app automatically offers protection plans on elig...

    5(6)FreeCategory rank 30+3
    52.8
    score
    Adoption
    36
    Satisfaction
    67
    Momentum
    26
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  16. 16
    Claims & Warranty By Claimify

    Claimify is a powerful Shopify app designed to simplify the process of handling customer claims. Whether it's a refund request, return, exchange, or warranty.

    5(7)$9/moCategory rank 28+2
    50.7
    score
    Adoption
    40
    Satisfaction
    74
    Momentum
    20
    Price
    70
    View on the Shopify App Store
  17. 17
    OrderProtect

    A customizable Shopify App that helps store owners increase revenue by allowing customers to opt-in to pay an additional fee upon checkout.

    5(11)$29.99/moCategory rank 24+2
    50.6
    score
    Adoption
    51
    Satisfaction
    81
    Momentum
    20
    Price
    30
    View on the Shopify App Store
  18. 18
    Guide Protection + Returns

    Shipping Protection with Instant Resolutions The purpose of 'Guide Shipping Protection' is to alleviate the strain from Lost/Damaged/Stolen package...

    4.6(47)FreeCategory rank 10 0
    49
    score
    Adoption
    81
    Satisfaction
    19
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  19. 19
    Protectify Shipping Protection

    Offer branded shipping protection at checkout with Protectify—no third-party insurance needed. Reduce disputes, boost margins, and customize easily.

    5(3)FreeCategory rank 33+3
    48.4
    score
    Adoption
    30
    Satisfaction
    60
    Momentum
    26
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  20. 20
    Parcel Protect

    Parcel Protect is powered by NTI, Australia’s trusted name in shipping and logistics protection. We offer you and your customer’s peace of mind wit...

    5(3)FreeCategory rank 34+3
    48.4
    score
    Adoption
    30
    Satisfaction
    60
    Momentum
    26
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  21. 21
    ShipTection

    Increase revenue and protect your shipments with ShipTection. Reduce lost package claims, and improve customer trust with shipping insurance.

    4.7(34)FreeCategory rank 14 0
    48.2
    score
    Adoption
    72
    Satisfaction
    26
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  22. 22
    Corso

    Automate returns, warranties, tracking, & shipping protection for your Shopify store. Corso integrates with Klaviyo, Gorgias & your tech stack seamlessly.

    4.8(19)FreeCategory rank 20 0
    44.4
    score
    Adoption
    60
    Satisfaction
    29
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  23. 23
    Shipping Protection ‑Insurance

    Protect Your Orders Build Customer Trust

    5(6)Category rank 31+3
    43.8
    score
    Adoption
    36
    Satisfaction
    67
    Momentum
    26
    Price
    40
    View on the Shopify App Store
  24. 24
    Mulberry Product Protection

    When you install the app, our AI-driven product classification engine automatically finds warranty offers for every eligible product in your catalo...

    4.4(26)FreeCategory rank 15 0
    43.1
    score
    Adoption
    70
    Satisfaction
    12
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  25. 25
    My Product Registration

    Product registrations, warranty registration, warranty claims, authenticity checker,form builder and after-sales product cares for the best customer experience

    4.7(72)$15/moCategory rank 7 0
    42.9
    score
    Adoption
    87
    Satisfaction
    24
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    35
    View on the Shopify App Store
  26. 26
    InsureShield & CommerceShield

    Identify high-risk orders, offer protection at checkout, and protect shipments with real shipping insurance and fast claims payments backed by UPS Capital.

    3.8(41)FreeCategory rank 11 0
    42.5
    score
    Adoption
    79
    Satisfaction
    0
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  27. 27
    ShipProtect ShippingProtection

    Charge a % of Shopify cart value as shipping protection to increase revenue and customer peace of mind.

    4.2(36)Free · then $9.99Category rank 12 0
    42.5
    score
    Adoption
    77
    Satisfaction
    2
    Momentum
    0
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  28. 28
    ShipGuard: Shipping Protection

    Offer customizable in-house shipping protection against loss, damage, or theft. Automate claims, refunds, and reorders with seamless Shopify integration.

    4.3(13)Free · then $9.99Category rank 22+1
    42.2
    score
    Adoption
    55
    Satisfaction
    14
    Momentum
    18
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store
  29. 29
    Upsify: Shipping Insurance

    Offer official shipping insurance backed by a licensed insurer. Protect every order and generate revenue with seamless Shopify integration.

    5(2)$8.99/moCategory rank 38+4
    40.6
    score
    Adoption
    21
    Satisfaction
    50
    Momentum
    31
    Price
    80
    View on the Shopify App Store
  30. 30
    ShipSaver: Insurance & Labels

    You get Commercial Plus Pricing on USPS shipments. Our shipping insurance rates are discounted and provide an incredible value as your business gro...

    ()FreeCategory rank 47+25
    40
    score
    Adoption
    0
    Satisfaction
    50
    Momentum
    50
    Price
    100
    View on the Shopify App Store

How the score is calculated

The BestAppify Score is four measurements, each turned into a percentile against the other warranties and insurance apps and then weighted. It is computed from our own crawl of the App Store — no human ranks these, and no app can pay to move.

Adoption35%
Review count on a log scale. It is the only public proxy for how many stores actually run the app, and the log stops a single 43,000-review incumbent from flattening everything beneath it.
Satisfaction30%
The star rating, shrunk toward the category average in proportion to how few reviews back it. Half of all rated Shopify apps show exactly 5.0 off a median of four reviews, so the raw number separates almost nothing.
Momentum20%
Reviews gained and category-rank movement over the last 52 days, from our own daily snapshots of the App Store charts. An app losing ground scores badly here even if its lifetime totals look strong.
Price15%
A plan a live store can stay on for $0 takes the top of this component; paid apps are ranked cheapest-first across a narrower band, so price nudges the order without overruling thousands of merchants.

What it cannot see: whether the app is any good at the job. Nothing here reads the feature list or installs the app, so treat the score as a shortlist, not a verdict — it tells you which three or four of these 30 are worth an hour of your evening, and no more than that. Apps whose pricing the crawler could not read score below the paid range on price rather than in the middle of it, deliberately: a price you cannot check before installing is a cost too. Momentum is measured over the last 4 days — the run of days on which our coverage of this category has been complete enough for one day's rank to mean the same thing as another's. It is deliberately shorter for categories we finished crawling recently: a rank of 4th out of the 28 apps we had in July is not comparable to 6th out of 436 today, and treating it as though it were would have scored every established app in some categories as falling.

Related categories

App Store Weekly

The apps in your stack change quietly. We crawl every listing in the Shopify App Store daily and send one email a week: which apps renamed themselves, which rewrote what they promise, and what we found in the data.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Already running a few of these?

Run a free audit of your store to see what you have installed, which apps overlap, and where you are paying twice for the same job.

Run a free store audit